Facebook Twitter Instagram YouTube
    Nostalgia Central
    Banner
    • Home
    • Blog
      • Lists
      • Playlists
    • Television
      • Shows by Decade
        • 1950s Television
        • 1960s Television
        • 1970s Television
        • 1980s Television
        • 1990s Television
      • Shows by Genre
        • Comedy
        • Drama
        • Kids TV
        • Variety
        • News & Sport
        • Advertisements
      • Shows by Country
        • UK TV
        • USA TV
        • Australia & NZ TV
        • Canada TV
        • Europe TV
        • Japan TV
      • Shows A to K
        • Shows A
        • Shows B
        • Shows C
        • Shows D
        • Shows E
        • Shows F
        • Shows G
        • Shows H
        • Shows I
        • Shows J
        • Shows K
      • Shows L to Z
        • Shows L
        • Shows M
        • Shows N
        • Shows O
        • Shows P
        • Shows Q
        • Shows R
        • Shows S
        • Shows T
        • Shows U
        • Shows V
        • Shows W
        • Shows X
        • Shows Y
        • Shows Z
      • Shows 0 to 9
    • Music
      • Music by Decade
        • 1950s Music
        • 1960s Music
        • 1970s Music
        • 1980s Music
        • 1990s Music
      • Music A to K
        • Music A
        • Music B
        • Music C
        • Music D
        • Music E
        • Music F
        • Music G
        • Music H
        • Music I
        • Music J
        • Music K
      • Music L to Z
        • Music L
        • Music M
        • Music N
        • Music O
        • Music P
        • Music Q
        • Music R
        • Music S
        • Music T
        • Music U
        • Music V
        • Music W
        • Music X
        • Music Y
        • Music Z
      • Music 0 to 9
      • Genres
      • Music on Film & TV
      • One-Hit Wonders
      • Online Radio
    • Movies
      • Movies by Decade
        • 1950s Movies
          • Movies 1950
          • Movies 1951
          • Movies 1952
          • Movies 1953
          • Movies 1954
          • Movies 1955
          • Movies 1956
          • Movies 1957
          • Movies 1958
          • Movies 1959
        • 1960s Movies
          • Movies 1960
          • Movies 1961
          • Movies 1962
          • Movies 1963
          • Movies 1964
          • Movies 1965
          • Movies 1966
          • Movies 1967
          • Movies 1968
          • Movies 1969
        • 1970s Movies
          • Movies 1970
          • Movies 1971
          • Movies 1972
          • Movies 1973
          • Movies 1974
          • Movies 1975
          • Movies 1976
          • Movies 1977
          • Movies 1978
          • Movies 1979
        • 1980s Movies
          • Movies 1980
          • Movies 1981
          • Movies 1982
          • Movies 1983
          • Movies 1984
          • Movies 1985
          • Movies 1986
          • Movies 1987
          • Movies 1988
          • Movies 1989
        • 1990s Movies
          • Movies 1990
          • Movies 1991
          • Movies 1992
          • Movies 1993
          • Movies 1994
          • Movies 1995
          • Movies 1996
          • Movies 1997
          • Movies 1998
          • Movies 1999
      • Movies A to K
        • Movies A
        • Movies B
        • Movies C
        • Movies D
        • Movies E
        • Movies F
        • Movies G
        • Movies H
        • Movies I
        • Movies J
        • Movies K
      • Movies L to Z
        • Movies L
        • Movies M
        • Movies N
        • Movies O
        • Movies P
        • Movies Q
        • Movies R
        • Movies S
        • Movies T
        • Movies U
        • Movies V
        • Movies W
        • Movies X
        • Movies Y
        • Movies Z
      • Movies 0 to 9
    • Pop Culture
      • Fads
      • Toys & Games
      • Fashion
      • Decor
      • Food & Drink
      • People
      • Radio
      • Technology
      • Transport
    • Social History
      • 1950s Year by Year
      • 1960s Year by Year
      • 1970s Year by Year
      • 1980s Year by Year
      • 1990s Year by Year
      • Events
    Nostalgia Central
    Home»Television»Shows by Decade»1950s Television
    1950s Television Shows I Variety 3 Mins Read

    Is This Your Problem?

    Share
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest WhatsApp Reddit Email

    1 9 5 5 – 1 9 5 7 (UK)
    30 minute episodes

    An early precursor of “reality TV”, this BBC programme debuted on 15 September 1955 and was broadcast live to air and dealt – very publicly – with viewers’ real-life difficulties.

    Members of the public appeared on the show to present a problem to an expert panel consisting of a doctor (specifically a “consultant physician who specialises in psychological medicine in one of our national hospitals”), a University Vice-Chancellor and a representative of the clergy.

    The first panel comprised JF Wolfenden (Vice-Chancellor of Reading University), the Rev. Leslie Weatherhead (President of the Methodist Conference) and Dr Stafford Clark (a leading psychiatrist who, in accordance with the medical convention of the time, was not named).

    The problems varied considerably, although the biggest batch of letters reportedly “dealt with housing difficulties, matrimonial conflicts, as well as erring husbands, delinquent children, adoption . . . emigration and people made unhappy by physical disability”.

    A programme where a panel discusses people’s most personal problems – with the person concerned on the screen – seemed designed to appeal to morbid curiosity and exploit worry and suffering to gain sentimental and emotional results in the viewing audience, but the BBC insisted the programme was designed to instruct and spread knowledge among the viewers.

    Edgar Lustgarten and Edana Romney (pictured) – who devised the series and appeared in it – were respectively a journalist and crime specialist trained in law and a well-known South African actress.

    Romney’s role was to explain the problem. She would then hand over to Lustgarten whose role was to clarify the problem and to ask the person questions, bringing out the facts and positioning the situation in an almost clinical light.

    Once he had finished procuring the facts, the panel would then take turns to give their view on the problem. Those with perplexities of a very personal nature who wished to remain anonymous were seated in a high-backed chair, turned away from the camera and seen only obliquely or in silhouette.

    The BBC claimed that about half of the cases dealt with on the show were fully and happily resolved due to the panel’s advice, coupled with private talks they always had with the people afterwards.

    Many were put in touch with the right people to help them in their own regions.

    Undoubtedly there were many in the millions who viewed Is This Your Problem? who sought guidance for themselves in the anonymity of their own homes.

    Is This Your Problem? aired fortnightly on Wednesdays at 9:15 pm initially and was later moved to 10:15 pm. The final edition was broadcast on 28 March 1957.

    Related Posts

    • Continental Classroom
      Continental Classroom
      1 9 5 8 - 1 9 6 4 (USA) Produced by NBC in cooperation with the American Association of Colleges…
    • Danger
      Danger
      1 9 5 0 - 1 9 5 5 (USA) 239 x 30 minute episodes This live half-hour CBS dramatic anthology…
    • First Impressions
      First Impressions
      1 9 6 4 (UK) Based on the American daytime game show, Your First Impression, this short-lived BBC panel game show…
    • Looking and Seeing
      Looking and Seeing
      1 9 5 7 (UK) 8 x 30 minute episodes Looking and Seeing was the very first television programme specifically for…
    • What's The Story?
      What's The Story?
      1 9 5 1 - 1 9 5 5 (USA) This innocuous panel show had the distinction of being the last…
    • Animal, Vegetable, Mineral?
      Animal, Vegetable, Mineral?
      1 9 5 2 - 1 9 5 9 (UK) 114 x 30 minute episodes Animal, Vegetable, Mineral? debuted on 23…
    • It's All In Life
      It's All In Life
      1 9 7 2 - 1 9 7 3 (UK) 8 x 30 minute episodes Popular radio comedian Al Read took…
    • Open University
      Open University
      1 9 7 1 - Current (UK) Britain's Open University is an innovative and highly successful distance-learning programme that utilises a…

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest WhatsApp Reddit Email
    Previous ArticleHard Knocks (1980)
    Next Article Trini Lopez, singer and Dirty Dozen actor, dead at 83

    Comments are closed.

    NC Radio Player
    Search the site

    Nostalgia Central has been a labour of love since 1998. The site carries no advertising, and I rely on donations to help with running costs and to keep the site running for your entertainment and education.

    If you find the site informative or enjoyable, please consider a donation – no matter how small. 

    Thank you so much.
    Enjoy your trip in the time machine!

    You may also like

    • Any Questions
      Any Questions
      1 9 5 8 - 1 9 6 3 (Australia) 30 minute episodes This weekly television panel discussion show from the…
    • Tell The Truth 
      Tell The Truth 
      1 9 5 7 (UK) 51 x 30 minute episodes 1 9 5 9 (UK) 14 x 30 minute episodes 1…
    • Top Town
      Top Town
      1 9 5 4 - 1 9 6 1 (UK) Beginning as a radio series in 1950, Top Town was an inter-town…
    • Free Speech
      Free Speech
      1 9 5 5 (UK) ITV introduced Free Speech, political cross-talk between Robert Boothby, W J Brown, Michael Foot and historian and…


    Nostalgia Central covers the period 1950 to 1999 and contains some words and references which reflect the attitudes of those times and which may be considered culturally sensitive, offensive or inappropriate today.
    Copyright © 1998, 2023 Nostalgia Central. Run by volunteers. Funded by donations.
    • About Nostalgia Central
    • Contact
    • FAQ

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.