One of the first Hollywood-produced combat flicks (alongside Robert Aldrich’s earlier Attack!) to truly deliver on its promised anti-war message, Hell Is For Heroes was originally crafted as a showcase for the emerging Steve McQueen but ended up in the accomplished hands of director Don Siegel.
Writer/director Robert Pirosh (who’d won an Oscar for scripting William Wellman’s 1949 Battle of the Bulge drama Battleground, and went on to create US TV’s classic ’60s WWII drama Combat!) based his original script on the true story of seven massively outnumbered GIs in 1944, ordered to hold their position on the Siegfried Line against an entire German company until reinforcements arrived.
After polishing up a final draft (entitled Separation Hill) in consultation with his star, Pirosh shot a week’s footage before the ever-capricious McQueen demanded a rewrite that increased his screen time and reduced the importance of Pirosh’s ensemble cast, which boasted the cream of Hollywood’s young acting talent.
Pirosh refused, so Paramount kicked him off his own flick and replaced him with Siegel.
It was the best thing that could have happened to the now-retitled Hell Is For Heroes.
Despite Pirosh’s pedigree as a writer of war dramas, his slender output as director languishes in justifiable obscurity, with only his remarkable 1951 Japanese-American soldiers-at-war opus Go For Broke! worth seeing, while Siegel was about to kick-start 10 years of unparalleled creativity.
Hell Is For Heroes bristles with the snappily-edited emotional urgency honed on B-movie classics like Invasion of the Body Snatchersand Baby Face Nelson that soon became his trademark.
Filmed over several weeks (with the woods of Redding, California) standing in for wartime France, Siegel’s movie unfolds over 48 desperate hours as the men of 2nd Squad are reassigned to the Siegfried Line.
Joined by the insubordinate, battle-scarred Private Reese (McQueen), no amount of well-drilled discipline or jovial bonhomie can disguise the lone squad’s sense of doom.
They’re already dead, and they know it.
Despite Siegel and rewrite man Richard Carr’s brief to big up McQueen, Hell Is For Heroes works precisely because Siegel, ever the wily professional, placated his needy star and stayed true to Pirosh’s ensemble vision.
Sure enough, McQueen is mesmerising, as he always was with the right director. Sporting a scrubby beard and a snarling fuck-you attitude, he’s a killer defined by war, living for combat and left incapable of forming human relationships.
McQueen may be the undoubted star, but Siegel serves the rest of the cast well. The film is stuffed with deadly-earnest performances, most of which serve to accentuate the random, ever-present carnage.
From James Coburn’s wry, fatalistic mechanic Henshaw to Mike Kellin’s displaced family man Kolinski and Harry Guardino’s raging Sgt Larkin, Siegel takes the usual Hollywood Gl stereotypes and relentlessly subverts them.
Comic relief comes briefly from hustling Private Corby (played so well by ailing Vegas crooner Bobby Darin that you wish he’d devoted his short life to movies rather than lounge-core classics) and green-as-they-come decoy Private Driscoll (comedian Bob Newhart in his feature film debut).
But even their light-hearted schtick ends in sober desperation as Siegel delivers a bleak monochrome vision of the European theatre of war at its most unforgiving.
This slice of cinematic combat wouldn’t be matched for intensity until Saving Private Ryan almost 40 years later.
Even then, Spielberg couldn’t resist a climactic blaze of flag-waving optimism. No such conclusion for Siegel, ever the dark-hearted nihilist.
Hell Is For Heroes ends with 2nd Squad decimated, their sacrifice instantly forgotten as the battle rages heedlessly on and Siegel’s camera zooms in on the unimpressive lone pillbox they’ve sacrificed everything to destroy.
War is hell.
Pvt. John Reese
Steve McQueen Pvt. Dave Corby
Bobby Darin Sgt. Bill Pike
Fess Parker Sgt. Jim Larkin
Harry Guardino Cpl. Frank Henshaw
James Coburn Pvt. James Driscoll
Bob Newhart Homer Janeczek
Nick Adams Sgt. Morgan
Stephen Ferry Pvt. Stan Kolinsky
Mike Kellin Thomas
Simon Prescott Capt. Roger Loomis
Joseph Hoover Jeep Driver
Robert Phillips Pvt. Joe Cumberly
Bill Mullikin Supply Sgt. Frazer
L.Q. Jones Capt. Mace
Don Haggerty Monique Ouidel
Michèle Montau
When Worlds Collide (1951) Before there was Deep Impact (1998) and Armageddon (1998), world destruction was done up in 1950s sci-fi style. The rights to…
Up Front (1951) Bill Mauldin’s battle-weary dog faces, Willie and Joe, from his famous World War II cartoons, come…
Darby's Rangers (1958) Veteran director William Wellman brings a little bit of romance, a touch of comedy, and then…
Mean Streets (1973) "You don’t make up for your sins in church. You do it in the streets." Charlie…
After polishing up a final draft (entitled Separation Hill) in consultation with his star, Pirosh shot a week’s footage before the ever-capricious McQueen demanded a rewrite that increased his screen time and reduced the importance of Pirosh’s ensemble cast, which boasted the cream of Hollywood’s young acting talent.
Filmed over several weeks (with the woods of Redding, California) standing in for wartime France, Siegel’s movie unfolds over 48 desperate hours as the men of 2nd Squad are reassigned to the Siegfried Line.
From James Coburn’s wry, fatalistic mechanic Henshaw to Mike Kellin’s displaced family man Kolinski and Harry Guardino’s raging Sgt Larkin, Siegel takes the usual Hollywood Gl stereotypes and relentlessly subverts them.
This slice of cinematic combat wouldn’t be matched for intensity until Saving Private Ryan almost 40 years later.
